Skip to main content

tv   Trump Trial Today  CNN  April 19, 2024 3:00pm-4:00pm PDT

3:00 pm
historic hush money case unfold, opening statements now set to begin monday as a full jury and a panel of six alternates are selected and sworn in. our reporters and experts are all standing by to break down all of today's most important developments and look ahead to what's next. welcome to our viewers here in the united states and around the world. i'm wolf blitzer with a special report in the situation room the trump trial today our special coverage. >> this our begins with the breaking news. the judge overseeing donald trump's criminal trial says, opening statements will begin on monday. jury selection in the case. now, officially complete. let's check in with cnn let's kara scannell outside the courthouse in manhattan. kara, you were there inside inside the courtroom for today's dramatic proceedings. give us the latest will trump, donald
3:01 pm
trump's legal team tried to were saying that some of the events they want to bring up, such as the e jean carroll allegations are attenuated to what is at trial in this case. now the judge has said that he would rule on this on monday, but it also came as trump's legal team made a last-ditch effort to try to stop this trial before it starts, they went to an appeals court today asking a judge to issue an emergency motion to grant the emergency motion to stop the trial so they could challenge it over venue because they've been arguing. they've been unable to find and fair and impartial jury in new york. now this coming within hours of the judge actually empaneling 12 jurors and six alternates after they selected the final five alternates in this case, which is expected to kick off on monday opening statements.
3:02 pm
now plan to start monday in former president donald trump's hush money trial after jury selection concluded, seating 12 jurors and six alternates. we have our full panel. that announcement from judge juan vr, schon after jury selection concluded at manhattan nights 12 jurors and six alternates have now been seated for now. so this is going to week and this will go on for another four or five weeks is very unfair. trump probe potential jurors until they filled the remaining five alternate seats. >> in court. a handful of perspective jurors became emotional one was excused after she told the judge she had anxiety and was worried as the trial goes on, more people could know she's part of the jury saying, i might not be able to be completely fair and not emotional. so that concerns me. another was dismissed after she began crying saying, i'm sorry, i thought i could do this. i wouldn't want someone who feels this way to judge my
3:03 pm
case either i don't want you to feel i've wasted anyone's time. this is so much more stressful than i thought. a third was sent home after noting she was feeling anxiety and self-doubt as she listened to a line of questioning about the credibility of witnesses at the defense table. trump's set flipping through papers with charts, photos, and graphics. he whispered and passed notes with his lawyers and at some points was hunched over with his elbows on the desk. prosecutors susan hauwa fingers started off questioning potential jurors, telling them this is not about mr. trump being a former president, is not about his being a candidate for the presidency. it's only about whether the evidence proves he's guilty during her presentation, trump leaned back in his chair at one point, his eyes closed trump's attorney, susan necklace focused on bias against the former president. she told those in the jury box, you all bring biases and you particularly bring biases about someone who is as publicly he and outspoken as president trump. there's nobody that doesn't know him in this room
3:04 pm
now, trump's lawyers tried to once again to get the prosecutors to tell them who the first witness will be, that they'll call in the case the most prosecutor said they would do is tell them on sunday, and the prosecutor said, if former president in tweets or makes any comments about that witness, it will be the last time they give them a heads-up. wolf. >> all right. kara scannell in new york for us. thank you. other action in the trump courtroom today? arguments over whether prosecutors can bring up donald trump, his past legal issues if he chooses to testify. i want to bring in our senior legal analyst, elie honig, for a closer look. ellie walk us through the so-called sandoval hearing. >> well, we'll think of a sandoval motion as a warning shot. this is the way that prosecutors here in new york advise any criminal defendant in any case here in new york. if you take the stand, of course, we will cross-examine you about the actual charges, but we're also going to cross-examine you about these other bad facts that you engaged in. and here, there's three main things that prosecutors say they want to cross-examine donald trump on.
3:05 pm
if big if he takes the stand. first of all, is the recent verdict against him in civil court over the trump civil fraud case, the allegation that donald trump was involved in inflating the value of his assets the second thing prosecutors want to bring up is the e jean carroll verdict for sexual assault and for defamation and the third thing that prosecutors say they'd like to cross-examine donald trump on outside the scope of these charges is a recent lawsuit that donald trump filed against hillary clinton, which was thrown out of court by a judge for being frivolous. and so the judge has not ruled yet on this, and he has said we'll have a ruling on monday and this may well informed drunk donald trump's ultimate decision whether he's going to take the stand and testify. >> le talk to us a little bit more about the appeals court hearing today involving trump's requests for a change of venue yeah well, so donald trump has tried yet again to pause this hearing and to try to get the case moved out of the borough of manhattan. that was denied. the judge said, we're not pausing this trial now donald trump's key argument is he is very
3:06 pm
politically unpopular in the borough of manhattan in new york county. and he is correct as a factual matter, if we look back at the 20 2020 election, donald trump got a little over 12% of the vote and manhattan, and that's the only borough where we're drawing our jury from. just by comparison, in staten island donald trump got 57% of the vote. we go to queens. he got 27% of the vote. he got 22 and brooklyn& he got about 16 in the bronx. that's said this is not the test for moving a case out to another venue. it's not about whether a person's popular or unpopular, it's about whether the person can get a legally fair trial. and the prosecutors team today pointed to jury selection. they said, look, we just read it out. hundreds of people who said, i'm to bias, i can't sit on this case and they argued the jury we ended up with as the result of a fair process. therefore, the cation stay in manhattan, and manhattan, it shall stay. >> all right. who are the alternatives? who got seated today? ally? >> so now we have our final alternate jurors. these are
3:07 pm
people who will only serve if we lose one of the main jurors. there's a lot we actually don't know about these folks, alternate juror number two, not working does not follow the news that may make her more neutral. number three, all we know is it's a native new yorker who's interested in martial arts draw whatever conclusion you will from that number for reads the times writer's bbc and is a contract specialist. we have another person who was a professional and then our last two alternate jurors, one of them works for a clothing company, gets her news from google. the last one is a project manager. interestingly, her father was convicted of a federal crime. not clear which way that would push, but wolf, it's important understand if we do have to dip into the alternate tier, alternate one will be the first one in then number two. so as we go farther and farther back in these alternate, it becomes less and less likely that any of these folks will ever actually make it get onto the jury. six altered and sorry, ellie will watch it together with you. >> thank you very much for joining us. now, let's get some more analysis from our legal and political experts and paula reid, euro or chief legal affairs correspondent. i'm
3:08 pm
anxious for your thoughts. give us your analysis of what the trump team is trying to keep out of this trial and y well, it's interesting. trump has so many legal issues everything from allegations of mishandling classified materials to allegations of fraud, to sex abuse. and here the argument is really focused on his civil matters. and i think it's going to be difficult for the defense attorneys to keep out a lot of this conduct because there's so much overlap with the case itself. their strongest arguments seems to be look, there's a different standard preponderance of the evidence that has much lower than a criminal court. it could confuse the jury, but for example, when it came to the hillary clinton lawsuit, uh, judges said, look, if this isn't sandoval at this isn't relevant. i don't know what is so not a great sayyed for the defense team. we bring in on chris khardori, a former federal prosecutor this conversation, how do you expect the judge to rule i expect he will let most, if not all of that come in because the differences between the standard civil and criminal that can be explained to the jury. and donald trump's
3:09 pm
lawyers can get into that if if that were to come up but the thing that all of those three categories of evidence but ellie described having common is they all concern his honesty, his truthfulness is reliability, right? the defamation is about him lying about e. jean carroll, the civil fraud cases about him lying about his financial assets, the frivolous hillary clinton lawsuit is about him being reckless with regard to the truth. all of those things, i do think would bear on a defendant's credibility if they took the stand if he takes the stand, do you think the judge will allow all that to come up? >> i think most, if not all, really very interesting, kristen, or why do you think trump is so insistent on testifying, taking the stand, even though his lawyers probably you're telling him don't do i'm not sure that he says early so insistent on taking the stand. >> i think he's so insistent on saying that he might take the stand and donald trump wants to control the media narrative. and if he continues to say that he might take the stand, there will be a whole will he won't he back-and-forth? i will remind you what this is not the first time that he said he's going to take the stand only to later changes mind say that his lawyers talked him out of it.
3:10 pm
there's actually only one time that he said he was going to take the standard, wasn't forced to. it was in the e jean carroll okay. is he stepped up there, it was very quick, very brief. he just wanted to answer one question and then got off the stand. let's remember what this case is about at its heart, a very salacious topic, donald trump and alleged affair with a porn star, then hush money payments to cover up that alleged affair. that is not something donald trump wants to talk about or answer questions on. >> yeah, that's a good point. you're making an excellent point. the shan wu is with us as well. we're looking ahead to the opening arguments, the opening statements on monday, assuming that happens on monday how do you think the manhattan district attorney's team will approach these opening statements? >> i think they'll try and keep it to a very simple story, which is, we're going to tell you about payments. we're going to talk about how they lied about the payments were gonna tell you why the lied about them and by focusing on that very simple narrative then you have the documents to prove those things and then you also have the witnesses who will kind of give in life and refer to the documents.
3:11 pm
>> what about the defense trump's lawyers? what do you think they're gonna do? >> well, i think we're going to hear a lot about michael cohen from the defense they're going to undercut his credibility. he certainly has credibility issues based on his conviction on his continued attacks on the defendant here, but he can be rehabilitated. he's still a witness that they can use. and i think in addition to trying to undercut his credibility in the eyes of the jury, they're also going to talk about his role at this time and the trump from orbit and perhaps her to argue that, look, he was actually doing legal work at the time in question. this isn't fraud, these aren't falsifying documents. he was as it says, in these documents, doing work for the trump the trump family for the trump organization. he was doing what he had always done. so i think we're going to start to hear a lot about michael cohen. >> he was trump's lawyer. he was the so-called fixer. we all know all about that. i'm crushed. what do you think i think michael cohen is going to be a major part of the opening. >> he is, as we currently understand the case, a key part
3:12 pm
of the da's case on that could change as a introduce evidence that may corroborates cohen. obviously, there have been some folks on the witness list who were all sort of wondering what are they going to be testifying about but at least out of the gate, i would expect donald trump's lawyers to really be hammering on cohen and basically saying this man is completely unreliable. he's lived every branch of the federal government in the last few years. you shouldn't believe them now, if you don't believe them now you need to acquit donald trump. >> and one thing i do want to add here about michael cohen is obviously donald trump has his gag order in place where he's not allowed to talk about the witnesses, but that does not apply to his small army of right-wing social media influencers. they are given the same access to information that all of us journalists are given. they're seeing pool reports and they're not going to have the same restriction let's say we do our limitations. that's going to apply to both jurors, but also attacking michael cohen. they are going to work to paint him as a liar. they are going to work to say that this case is based off of the testimony of a liar and you're going to see pretty hard, harsh, vitriol when it comes to these
3:13 pm
witnesses, particularly from these right? wing social media influencers and from donald trump's allies. >> what do you think show oh, i think that's a really great point. and i think it raises for judge mission ultimately, the question of does he have to reconsider? sequestration of the jury. he may have to do that at the time of deliberations, but especially with the kind of pressure that has been put on the jurors. he may have been a little bit overconfident and thinking you can manage that he did a great job of getting through the selection but you're beginning to see some of the stress appearing in the jurors. he may end up having to go kinda deepens that alternate bull two. so that's something has got to consider. of course, earlier in the week, you express concern about the safety of the jurors. >> they're under enormous pressure as we all know, what do you think? yeah. i mean, i completely go what these two just said. i'm also concerned turned about not established media organizations, but the peripheral folks who are getting the same pool reports. we are, we all are and frankly, just pull reports have way more
3:14 pm
information that credible news outlets, when we saw what we put up for it, we're trying to protect the identity, particularly after we saw what happened was are number two, who ask to be dismissed because there were called she said she got saying that there were identifying factors asking her up. she was the juror, so we have become more careful there. remember the judges only rule here was using common sense. what we use for common sense is not going to be the same as what these right-wing media influencers, people who are pro-donald trump, but going to use, i think one thing recent saw today, evidently, all of these folks getting up and talking about how stressful this is, i have to say those some of those comments were a little upsetting to me. have to hear our fellow americans were really just trying to do their civic duty going through all of this stress, sitting on the first ever criminal prosecution potentially of a former president this not be a country where president in the lawn trial and americans are afraid to be on the jury because we may have to do it three more times if there were more
3:15 pm
trials. biggest, i'm really worried myself. >> i'm sure you are as well about the safety of these jurors. >> yeah. no doubt. i think when we all heard that oncology nurse yesterday say, look, i just i can't do that. this after she had been selected no one question that everyone understands that, you some of us have drawn the ire of trump and know what that feels like and what that brings for you and your family. it's an enormous ask of any citizen to be on this jury. it's hugely important, but it absolutely comes with risks it's an important point, our guys. thank you very, very much. just ahead, we'll take a closer look at just win and alternate juror would be needed, including what happens if the case runs out of alternates, who can step in. but first we're looking at the big decisions. the judge is weighing as both sides prepare for the opening statements, a former new york judges, dan me biden, discuss with us live stay with us you're in the situation there's new ally in the fight against climate change. >> this is in carpus is blue
3:16 pm
carbon weekend me to protect nature will be the rest. >> blue carbon plus cnn fill sunday at nine we add here surround your lawn with scott's tough builders or if an action it gets freed up is done at once. >> killed swedes prevents cab gas a keeps it grown strong dello the my line david one care tips and customize play phi did law why always the couch? no we've been spending all this little guy. >> when your questions about life turn into questions about money. there's erica, the virtual financial assistance to help you spend save& plan smarter only from bank of america what would you like the power to do businesses go further with 5g solutions. >> that's why they choose t-mobile for business pga of
3:17 pm
america and t-mobile for partnering on five gene powered analytics to help improve player performance t-mobile's network helps aaa stay connected nationwide to give their members back on the road and las vegas grand prix chose t-mobile to help fuel operations for one of the world's largest racing events. now is the time to see what america's largest by gene network can do for your business goldilocks needs a place of her own and fast thankfully, she's on redcap. they update the enlistees every two minutes. and with so many options, she's bound upon exactly what she wants. >> this one's just right she tashi duncan, attorney whole family into a millionaire. >> how does this happen for the same girl? >> it's not in, love with you. >> what makes you think i want someone be in love with me challenger pseudo, april 26
3:18 pm
when you're a, small business owner you to do less can be a lot that's why progressive makes it easy to save with a commercial auto quote online. so you can take on all your other to-dos already did see if you could say that progressive commercial.com did you know there's no t in skechers when he told about rodolphe is always been scheduled z and these get to slippery is ten. these sketches libyans wow,
3:19 pm
incredible, amazing my go-to is lumify eye lumify dramatically reduces redness in one minute and look at the difference. >> my eyes brighter and wider for up to eight hours, lumify, kind of amazing see for yourself. >> manu raju on capitol hill in this is cnn close captioning brought to you by gilt visit gilt.com today for up to 70% of designer brands, it has the designers that get your heart racing had inside a prices new every day curry, they'll be gone in a flash. >> designer sales at up to 70% or so. i'll get delta.com
3:20 pm
today we're back with our special coverage of the trump trial. >> de for tonight, donald trump on truth, social is posting about judge juan merchan writing in part, and i'm quoting, judge, version is railroading me at breakneck speed in order to completely satisfy his quote, friends let's discuss with shira scheindlin, a retired us district court judge for the southern district of new york, judge. thank you so much for joining us. how do you think, judge merchan could address this latest attack against him and the other cases prosecutors flag that they say violated the gag order in the upcoming hearing on that issue. >> well, i think the best thing he could do is not responded. all that's the wisest way to deal with a like that say nothing. it's a mistake for a judge to get drawn into it. >> also today, in this so-called sandoval hearing judge merchan said he'll decide by monday whether prosecutors can bring up trump's past
3:21 pm
legal cases. how do you expect him to rule? >> well, you know, the sandoval rule is that it has the questioning has to go to credibility, honesty, and veracity. and so many of the items that the people want to put in go directly to veracity, credibility and honesty. but the judge's job mr. weigh the probative value of that testimony against the prejudice. so it's always prejudicial to a defendant to have bad prior bad acts mentioned on the other hand, the probative value is high on some of these things so the prior finding that his testimony was not honest before judgment, judge engoron, that goes directly to credibility and honesty it's the same is true of the yeah, the same is true of the defamation case because by definite by definition, you can't commit defamation unless it's false. if it's truthful, it's not
3:22 pm
family story. so by definition, it's false. so that also goes to honesty, credibility veracity. so i expect he will certainly let those two n. now, this recent lawsuit against hillary clinton, it's frivolous. >> i'm not sure. best it goes to credibility, that one to me is closer, but the problem i believe let that into, but what you won't let him or shouldn't let in for example, is sexual assault or rape because while those are heinous crimes, they don't go to veracity credibility, or honesty and that's the rule addressing trump also complained, is, you know, about judge versions pacing, pacing of this trial outside the courtroom only moments ago, he said this, watch and listen and minor, which is long before a lot of people fled, the judge wants to go to fast as possible? the histories and is enough for my residence. >> what do you make that is this trial moving at the pace you expected well honestly i
3:23 pm
thought it would take longer to pick a jury in state court, but i admire the way he handled it. >> he's moved it along quickly, which is probably the right thing to do in this particular case. the longer it takes, the longer people are going to have second thoughts. it's good to get the jury is seated and sworn. i think he did it fairly in every way and i don't think it was overly fast. i think it was thorough, it carefully planned. a good questionnaire. the lawyers had time to ask their questions. so while it was faster than i expected, i don't think he was railroaded and i don't think it's too fast. >> as you know, judge, there's been a lot of scrutiny over juror number 11, who said she doesn't like trump's persona, that she thinks he seems very selfish and self-serving direct quotes. were you surprised that judge merchan didn't dismiss her? would you have done so in his shoes? >> i probably would have dismissed or i think there was
3:24 pm
a fair challenge for cause there and there were so many more jurors available to be questioned that i wouldn't i wouldn't have kept this particular one. what's the point if she really has these preconceived views of the defendant? not not necessarily his conduct, but of him, then she's predisposed against him. and i don't think that's fair, so i think he would have been wiser to grant the challenge for cause and voir dire some other jurors, there were hundreds and waiting good point that going into the opening statements next week, we think they're going to take place on monday. >> how does judgment don balanced treating trump like a normal criminal defendant with the extraordinary circumstances of this case well, i don't know quite what you mean by normal. >> he's a defendant in a criminal trial. he's not going to be making an opening statement. his lawyers have to be making opening statements. and i'm sure the judge has asked them how long they expect to take, and i'm sure the judge will give them the time they
3:25 pm
need but if they cross a line that the judge thinks is inappropriate, and there's an objection, then he will interrupt and sustain the objection. but i think he'll hopefully let the lawyers do their job. these are good lawyers. i think the judge backs them. i think they'll do they'll do what they have to do. >> judge. shira scheindlin. thanks so much for joining us. want to continue our conversation down the road. appreciate it very much coming up. we'll take a closer look at what's on the docket monday in the case of the people of new york versus donald j. trump, plus a lawyer who defended donald trump and one of his previous trials is standing by to join us live every piece of evidence tells a story how it really happened with jesse l. martin sunday, april 28th at nine on cnn on the left, your mouthwash with the burning sensation in on the
3:26 pm
right closest the alcohol-free gentle mouthwash that works without the burn closest mouthwash is fresh and breath. improved gum health, and strengthened team. >> closest works without the burn it's better outside with ninja cook outs master grills, the char barbecue smoking they are for that yard bashes or better with pizza ovens, they give you krispy kreme, 700 degree high heat roasting and barbecue smoke it's better outside with ninja. stay tuned to learn more about this limited time offer from renewal by anderson. >> have you been looking at replacing your home's windows or doors? if so, i'm sure price is a huge factor. >> a renewal by anderson we're really proud of our fair pricing policy, where a typical middle-class family, we have a budget, we need to be aware of where money is going and the great thing about renewal by anderson was they actually had several financing options that we're going to make sense for our situation. >> so let's talk, windows are five rx window material is like
3:27 pm
the gold standard in the industry. it's a composite material that last longer performs better and is actually two times stronger than vinyl. >> okay, so you're carrying this out to your back deck? >> but you've got to stop and try to shove open that patio door that can be really frustrating the dual ball bearing adjusters on our patio doors help the doors to glide easily. >> renewal by anderson, we've been doing this a long time and we know that you don't want some hard sell sales pitch will visit your home, see exactly what you have, and then give you the exact price book and will honor that price for a whole year so that there's no pressure let us give you a price on the windows and doors that you will love we have the intention of looking at different companies doing some due diligence and we started with renewal by anderson and it was such a compelling conversation and process that we ended up not even looking any further before april 30th by one window, patio door, or entry door, and get the next
3:28 pm
one, 40% off. that's 40% off with a minimum of four units plus save an extra $30 on every window and door you buy with no money down, no monthly payments, and no interest for one year this offer ends april 30th for a free appointment with renewal by anderson call one 800 that's what 805011400 i've never once had to wait for insurance to approve a test are proven medication, you didn't have to worry about any of those things. >> thanks to the donations and our family is forever grateful because it's completely changed our lives for gentle, dependable, constipation really tries seneca, it works differently than other laxatives because it's made from the center flat and natural vegetable active ingredient gentle, dependable, my name is oluseyi and some of my favorite moments throughout my life are watching sports with my dad.
3:29 pm
now, i work at comcast as part of the team that created our ai highlights technology, which uses ai to detect the major plays in a sports game. giving millions of fans, like my dad and me, new ways of catching up on their favorite sport. and enjoy 20% off plus free shipping on your first-order am zachary cohen in washington in
3:30 pm
this is cnn let's get some more now on the opening statements of the trump trial. >> now set for monday morning, our senior legal analyst, elie honig is back with us, looking ahead to day five in court la what should we expect when the trial resumes on monday? well what we have are full jury? and so the next step is that the trial will start in earnest. we are here on our flowchart. we are going to hear opening statements from both sides and let me explain to you how this is going to play out. first of all, the da's office, the prosecutor's, they're going to go first. this is alvin bragg. he's the de, he's not going to be giving the opening artery he's not going to be trying this case. he will probably be in the courtroom to support his team, but a member of the da's team will open, followed by the opening for the defense in all likelihood, the defense actually does not have to open, but they probably will. todd blanche will be giving that opening for donald trump a couple of major themes that i think people should watch for in the opening statements. first of all, the indictment, what does it mean?
3:31 pm
the da is going to argue this is a bout donald trump's attempt to interfere in the 2016 election. donald trump's team will probably argue this is a paperwork offense from a long time ago that he never should have been charged with& that he's not guilty of. the second in theme, of course, will revolve around some of the witnesses michael cohen in particular, is a very high-stakes, very controversial witness, as you just discussed with your panel. and the final theme that we will here, we're going to hear a lot about the burden of proof. the defense lawyers in any case, they always remind the jury over and over again that the prosecution, they bear the burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. so listen for those three themes. when the parties open on monday, we'll watch it together with you, elie honig. thank you very, very much. let's get some more insight right now from robert rais served as counsel, the former president trump during his first impeachment robert, thanks so much for joining us. how do you think trump's team is working to craft opening statements for monday morning, take us inside the process
3:32 pm
well, the good thing for them, and it doesn't always happen in every case is that they have a weekend to prepare for this and so they will be working over the course of this evening and in through the throughout the weekend. >> and my guess is they'll probably do todd blanche is giving the opening statement a mock opening state i'm going to run through perhaps before jury consultants and a reaction to how that goes over with with mock jurors. and my guess also is that it will be a presentation in front of the client, in front of donald trump himself, who will be in a position to critique and amend and make suggestions as to what he thinks the opening should be. so there'll be plenty of time over the course of the weekend for the defense team to perfect that opening statement and it's an a very important moment in the case as elie just mentioned, the most important thing to drive home and remind the jurors is that at the end of the case, the defense will be asking for a verdict of not guilty. the government has the
3:33 pm
burden of proof to prove beyond a reasonable doubt unanimously to the satisfaction of all jurors that the defendant is guilty before they can reach a verdict of guilty. and that's the presumption of innocence is an important legal costs concept. in our judicial system in a criminal case, given the fact that potentially imprisonment is on the line and the seriousness of the case will be something that that will be a theme from todd blanche. i mean, i mean, obviously you have a critique of the evidence about what's the defense expects to show during the course of the trial. but he'll remind the jurors that the defendant doesn't have to do anything. he has no burden of proof. he doesn't have to present evidence. he doesn't have to testify in his own defense. and it remains the obligation of the government approved this case beyond a reasonable doubt robert, if you were trump's council in this case, would you be trying to convince him against taking the stand? can you know him well, can even be convinced ultimately, wolf, that's a call
3:34 pm
for the client to make. >> obviously, it is done with the advice of your lawyers, but it's one that only the defendant can make in most cases defendants don't testify and they don't because of the reasons that i just suggested that is that the government has the burden of proof and the defendant doesn't have to do anything. if you know, depending on how the evidence goes in at trial, if the lawyers on the client think that it went well and they rely on the presumption of innocence and the fact that the government has the burden of proof usually it behooves the defendant not to take the stand. that's advice. that it is often provided by defense counsel to the client and sometimes they take that advice and sometimes they don't. i will say that if donald trump decides over the objection of his lawyers to take the stand, my guess is that the lawyers will make a record before the judge out of the presence of the jury, that that was the advice that they gave& the client decided to reject it in
3:35 pm
favor of testifying in his own defense. >> yeah, that would be the reason they do that is because they're trying to protect themselves from any subsequent claim later on. >> that the lawyers provided ineffective assistance of counsel. yeah, that's a good point. >> let me get your thoughts while i have you, robert, on the now fully empaneled jury and the six alternates. >> is this a jury you would have agreed to seat if you were representing trump? >> i think there were appropriate objections made. you went over them with judge scheindlin about some i think questionable calls about whether or not certain jurors should have been excused for cause. the defense has made a record of that in the event of a conviction, i'm sure those issues will be ones that we'll return on appeal. and that may or may not warrant a new trial if an appellate court decides that even in the event of a conviction, donald trump didn't receive a fair trial because he didn't get a fair jury i think there can be reasonable disagreement of
3:36 pm
that, and obviously unless the error is serious, it's not likely to be one that would survive harmless error analysis, but they are still legitimate issues on appeal, which is why trials are such difficult things. and so those, those issues, there's a record that has been made. they've objected and in a timely fashion the court has ruled& will be up ultimately to an appellate courts decide whether or not that judge made the right call. we're not robert wray. thanks for your excellent analysis. we'll have you back for sure. thank you very much and just ahead glaring at the judge, flipping through papers, sometimes appearing board with the trial will get a first-hand account of donald trump's demeanor in court today? province cnn correspondent, who was in the room the entire time riyad say's new album is breaking records hey there,
3:37 pm
brenda it's carroll actually, which like are we operating on? >> you mean arm it's all connected, asking the right question can greatly impact your future. you share your an orthopedist i i'm a sagittarius especially when it comes to your finances, give a question. are you a certified financial planner? >> yes. i'm a cfp professional cop professionals are committed to acting in your best interest. >> that's why it's gotta be a cfb bind your cfp professional, and let's make a plan doubt or consumer cellular, we offer amazing 5g coverage backed up by incredible customer service. >> but that would mean much without super low prices you already know where half as much as the largest carriers. >> but guess what? arp numbers and can save even more and for a limited time, new customers get their second month free
3:38 pm
call 1888, freedom or visit consumer cellular.com, i guess i'm not the easiest person to please i like things just right that's why i love red pins home recommendations. >> they know what i want even before i do a home that's just right yeah yeah it's time yes. >> but time has come for a fresh approach to dog food every day moore dog people are deciding it's time to quit the kibble and feed their dogs fresh food from the farmers dog. made by vets. and delivered right to your door precisely? >> for your dog's needs. >> it's an idea whose time has come get into the rhythm of the
3:39 pm
eyelids and delighting the curve to be at state of mind. >> visit sandals.com, or haldwani hundred sandals when i take the bike out like this, all my stress is just melt away i hear that this bad boy i can fix anything tough day at work let's cruises sorts. >> you write out, when i'm writing, i'm not even thinking about my painful cavity he shouldn't know it. and every time i get stress about having to pay my bills and it's hop on the bike, man. >> and you gotta pay your bills. >> you don't have to worry about anything when you're protected by america's number one motorcycle insurer? >> well, you definit discount c
3:40 pm
to 50% over real stone khaimah, our lives signs in scranton, pennsylvania. >> and this is cnn tense moment and donald trump's trial today as judge juan merchan told
3:41 pm
trump attorneys, quote, you need to accept my emotions this in response to the defense attempts to file motions that were relitigating decisions. >> the judge had already made. let's bring in cnn's kara scannell. kara, i didn't trump respond to that moment. and how did he carry himself today? you were in that courtroom all day? >> so we'll during that moment, trump hadn't glared at the judge. he had a fixed stare at him as the judge is making a lot of comments that weren't necessarily going in trump's favor at the end of the hearing or what trump thought was the anti stood up to leave and the judge, who is not finished told him, please sit down, sir. but otherwise, during jury selection shan, which took up the entire morning, there was the routine moments or the 22 jurors were answering those 42 questions. and at that time, trump appeared to be leaning back at times he's closed his eyes. other times he was flipping through pieces of paper that didn't look like they were the questionnaire. they seem to have charts or graphs on them. but then when his attorneys began questioning the jurors furs and asking them
3:42 pm
specifically what their opinion was of donald trump. again, he turned his chair in their direction. he was craning as next, so he would be able to see them engaged again at that moment when they were being asked specifically their opinion of him while you're interested and kara scannell. thank you very much. joining us now, the former us attorney for the southern district of new york are good friend of the situation room preparer prix. thanks very much for joining us. what's your reaction to trump's demeanor today? and him saying, again, he would take the standard and fence will taking the second question first, i don't believe it for a minute. he has been talking for years with respect to various investigations of him, including by special counsel bob muller, and impeachment inquiry is that he was sit and give testimony. he's not gonna do it i think he likes to pretend that he has the fortitude and the courage to do that. i don't think he will with respect to his demeanor, i will tell you that it may be the case that at rallies and another political functions,
3:43 pm
when he acts an over ax and makes faces and does his thing people enjoy it, but this is not a maga rally it's 12 jurors who were sworn to uphold their oath as jurors. a sacrosanct duty, civic duty. and in my experience, there'll be watching the defendant in this case, donald trump very carefully and that they detect that the defendant, donald trump, is not taking the proceeding seriously or is contemptuous of them or it's not importing himself with respect towards the judge and the others in the room that a nurse to his detriment& i guarantee you, todd blanche, i know very well i used to work with him at the southern district of new york is mortified that his client is making faces. >> and doing things like that and obviously, the jury is going to take into account the evidence as it comes in but they're human beings and they will form an opinion of the sitting defendant if he if he acts out and it's probably not to his benefit. >> good point. >> looking ahead to monday can you put yourself in the prosecutors shoes and tell us how you would craft opening
3:44 pm
statements yes. >> so i think an opening statement is very powerful and important moment in the trial. in some ways, it's the most important moment at the trial. they've obviously had some exposure to the jury pool because there was a volunteer process this but it's the opening statement where the prosecution gets to set forth the basics of the case and the evidence that they're going to show. and. i think they want to resist being overly dramatic. they want to resist being histrionic. they want to be plain and simple. here. the fact here's what the evidence will show they also need to be careful not to over-promise. they have some interesting witnesses that have been mentioned on your show in the last hour including michael cohen. it's unclear and i'd probably believe in the minds of the prosecutors is unclear how smoothly that will go, both on direct examination cross-examination, and redirect examination. so they will want to tell the jury, we have these witnesses coming forward, including michael cohen. he's going to tell you this that and the other but they want to understate it a little bit and see how the evidence comes in.
3:45 pm
they don't want to gild the lily. they don't want to call names, they don't want to be overly aggressive about it. this is a plain and simple case. >> here's what we're going to prove here's how we're going to prove it. and listen to the instructions of the judge. and use your common sense and you'll come to the only verdict that is appropriate in this case. and that's guilty. it should be a good workman like opening statement in my view what do you make the prosecution's wariness against sharing their witness list with trump's legal team well you know, they have good reason to do that obviously, the defense knows the overall witness list. i think the question was whether or not they should be told the immediate witnesses coming forward so that as a matter of convenience, they know who to prepare for this weekend. and that's of some benefit as a professional. and usually that professional courtesy is extended. but as i think the judge said in the courtroom today, there's good reason prosecutors are wary of that because there's a track record here of donald trump repeatedly calling out those
3:46 pm
witnesses, his allies saying things about those witnesses. and he wants to prevent that as much as possible. so a little bit of a bold move because it's traditional for that courtesy to be extended but they have i think the favor of the judge here on deciding not to do so. >> good point to free pereira. >> welcome back to the situation thank you very much for joining us. >> thanks, sir coming up alternate jurors can go from the sidelines to the spotlight at a moment's notice we're taking a closer look at the reasons of when they could stepping qizan life. >> dr. sanjay gupta listen wherever you get your podcast, the future is not just going to happen, you have to make it. and if you want a successful business, all it takes is an idea.& now becomes a future where you grew at dream into a reality we all knew godaddy arrow put your business online in minutes with the power of ai vital window seem to be a typical choice here in the local area, some companies even
3:47 pm
advertise high-quality vinyl and romer here before you invest in vinyl windows, listened to what michael smith of renewal by anderson has to say with our temperature swings, vinyl tends to warp, which causes condensation between the pains and drafts. >> and most final windows just look very low-end to begin with. >> our customers don't want that and what are renewal by anderson's windows made of or windows are made out of a thermo polymer composite material called fiber x it's beautiful like wood, but it doesn't require the maintenance of wood. and we engineered it to be two times stronger than vinyl. so you're getting a window that will really last. >> now, this is innovation. you have a feature on your windows that allows for a better view. >> are true seen screens are made of an ultra fine stainless steel mesh, which is virtually invisible. you get less dirt buildup, more fresh air circulation, and a better view out of your windows. >> now, if we're talking about comfort, how much does the glass matter? >> the glass in the window makes a huge difference. >> our high performance, low
3:48 pm
ephors, smart sunglass is infused with silver oxide. >> it's engineered to help keep the coal air outside in the winter and keep the warm air outside in the summer. it also blocks 95% of the harmful uv rays that fade your furniture and your hardwood floors. >> well, that's impressive. michael. thank you. >> and right now, renewal by anderson has a great offer for homeowners before april 30th by one window patio der or entry door, and get the next one, 40% off. that's 40% off with a minimum of four units plus save an extra $30 on every window and door you bye with no money down, no monthly payments, and no interest for one year. this offer ends april 30th for a free appointment with renewal by anderson call one 800 that's 1805011400 it's time to feed the dogs real food in the right amount. a healthy weight can help dogs live a longer,
3:49 pm
happier life. the farmers dog makes weight management easy with fresh food 3 portion for your dog's needs, it's an idea whose time has come luck and good guys situations are better with the credit god's on your side. comment for awards. >> once available to the few
3:50 pm
? yes, we have more than next, but it's still the website is next.com, great teammates crossing each other. we're going to do a trust walls stand up. you close your eyes for trust what the summary up doc i told you it was a dummy are back to the breaking news. the full jury for donald trump's hush money trial is now seated, and that includes six alternate jurors who will step in if one of the 12 permanent jurors is excused or dismiss cnn's brian todd is looking into this forest. brian, any one of these six alternates could be called upon at any time. they have to be ready. well, if you know the term alternate juror may not
3:51 pm
sound very glamorous, and it really isn't. but experts say in a trial this intense, don't discount the importance of the alternate already two empaneled jurors have been excused from former president trump's hush money trial, underscoring just how crucial the six alternate jurors are, who've just been seated in a case of this length and in a high-profile case, the alternates are as significant as the regular jury panel because there's a very high likelihood and probability in this case that one or more of those alternates are going to end up on the journey. >> the alternate juror is there to take over a spot on the 12 member regular jury if one of the regulars has to drop out of the trial one of the reasons could be illness they could have a family emergency or something else could happen like they can't follow the court's instruction not to post things on social media. >> court veterans say the life in limbo of an alternate juror can be strange, unsatisfying,
3:52 pm
and tougher than it may see. >> it's difficult to to be very present & to really focus as much as jurors might need to with the idea in the back of their mind that they might not really need to deliberate at the end of it. all but as one alternate juror in police officer derek chauvin, murder trial said being an alternate doesn't mean the case weighs on you any less heavily every night when i would come home, i i felt exhausted. >> it was pretty draining, pretty emotional and that juror didn't even know she was an alternate until the end of the trial in some cases, the judges purposely don't inform the jury of them are alternates and which are regulars until they start deliberating so they don't have that issue of knowing. >> i might not have to deliver. i do. i really filename to listen to this, there are six alternate jurors for trump's trial, while that may seem like a lot for a complex and highly charged case, it may not be enough. all right. he appears to have pulled the gloves off, council during a o.j. simpson's lengthy murder trial, ten regular jurors were
3:53 pm
dismissed for failing to disclose something allegedly passing a note or considering a book deal, or simply telling the judge i can't take it anymore ten alternate took their place what happens if the trump trial runs out of alternates would be up to the defendant whether or not he would want to consent to a verdict with 11 jurors, but i don't believe that he would do that in this case. and you would have a mistrial. >> the alternates are always important during the actual trial, but don't join the final deliberations unless they're needed. what happens if a regular juror has to leave the case during deliberations. >> what happens then is the real jury has to basically start over their deliberations. they have to deliberate as though they hadn't done the deliberations they'd done with the first with the original juror and start over with the alternate juror what's the best advice for an alternate juror? >> trial consultant? leslie lss tried to forget urine alternate participate in everything you can with the other jurors. pay attention to every bit of the evidence pretend that you're one of the first 12 because you may very well be at the very
3:54 pm
end woolven in the trial like this with its luck length, and intensity, you can count on it's very interesting. thanks, very much, brian todd for that report. >> coming up, we're going to break down the serious security concerns outside court after a man set himself on fire today, more on how new york police are reviewing their protocols that's next new ally in the fight against climate change. this is new car this is blue carbon. >> we just need to protect. nature will do the rest blue carbon plus cnn sunday at nine hello, ghostbusters get stuck. we help people customize and save hundreds on car insurance with liberty mutual the situation sure. i can make do this the rise discount i've run
3:55 pm
hour newest resorts, sandal st. vincent and the grenadines now open visit sandals.com or call one 800 sandals businesses go further with 5g solutions. >> that's why they choose t-mobile for business pga of america and t-mobile partnering one, five gene powered analytics to help improve player performance t-mobile's network helps aaa stay connected nationwide to give their members back on in the road. and las vegas grand prix joe's t-mobile to help fuel operations for one of the world's largest racing events. now is the time to see what america's largest biji network can do for your business dude, what are you doing protected my car. that's too much work.
3:56 pm
whether tech is so much easier here laser measured floor liners up here, seat protector, and cargo liner back there. nice out here side window deflectors and mudflats& the bump step keep the bumper debt-free cool. it's the best protection for your vehicle, new or pre-owned. >> great. but where do i order whether tech.com everywhere, but the seat to seat is 11. now, i get it. you love your bike? we did two. that's why we're americans number what motorcycle insurer. what do you have to wedge it and everything? >> well, don't do that reminds, me of my blank the wolf was about the size of my new motorcycle. >> have you seen it by the way around really lacava brushstrokes bottle the line of a gas tank problem of plus one jaime shopping online comes with digital threats. so turn on nord vpn steer clear of
3:57 pm
phishing websites and encrypt your online traffic get the deal now lag sunglasses lactate brand goldilocks needs a place of her own and fast thankfully, she's on redfin. >> they update their listings every two minutes and with so many options, she's bound to find exactly what you want. >> this one's just right she it is follow your pets every step with the world's most trusted gps tracker for pets, track your pets live location from anywhere in the world
3:58 pm
monitor their activity sleep, and good health alerts. so you can spot potential issues early. said virtual fences to get alerts if you're escape artists goes too far all in one, easy to use add with unlimited range and support and over 150 countries tractive, trusted by millions of pet parents around the world save 20% for a limited time we're here today to set the record straight about do patrons contracture surgery is not your only treatment option? >> well, may think they're contracture has to be severe to be treated, but it doesn't visit find a hand specialist.com today to get started erin burnett outfront next on cnn we're tracking new concerns around the trump trial after a man let himself on fire today just outside the courthouse, shortly after the incident, new york city police said security protocols might need to be reassessed. we are very concerned of course, we're
3:59 pm
going to review our security protocols. the park was open to the public. but of course, we're going to look at everything and what the magnitude of what's going on around right here. reassess our security. what i'll federal parties let's bring in our chief law enforcement and intelligence analyst, john miller. john give us the latest what's going on well, they're looking into the background of this gentleman while they're looking into the larger security picture, do they need to expand the perimeter? >> do they make do they need to make more of the area around that courthouse? a frozen zone? do they need to close the park, which is a place where people would go and demonstrators gather. and even if they do that, could somebody do something similar somewhere else? all that's on the table and they have the weekend to sort it out. but what we know about this man is he's a 36 year-old man from st. augustine, florida police down there have a record of encounters with him, things that may have to do with being emotionally unhinged he had a in-depth conspiracy theory and
4:00 pm
called the ponzi papers that he posted online. it has to do with banks cryptocurrency, universities, movie is murder plot let's it's very detailed and not much of it has anything to do with donald trump or the campaign. he did have a sign with him that said trump is with biden and they're about to fascist coup us, which is a sign of how disjointed his conspiracy theories are. his driver's license with just taped to the sign because he wanted to he wanted people to know who he was police theorize the reason he did this in front of the courthouse in the park, just adjacent to where the cameras were, was so that he could get national or global attention to what he was doing. and the weird theories that he's posted online behind john miller. thank you very much for that update. john miller helping us and to our viewers. thanks very much for watching. i'm wolf blitzer in the situation room. >> erin burnett, outfront
4:01 pm
star

40 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on